Conversion · 6 min read

How to increase repeat purchase rate on Shopify in 2027

Only 18.8% of DTC customers place a second order. Here is how Indian D2C brands on Shopify lift that number with better first orders, timed reminders and simple loyalty.

By the Pixel Caption growth team

A smiling customer opening a delivered parcel at her front door

Most of your customers buy once and leave

An analysis of more than 156,000 direct-to-consumer customers found an average repeat purchase rate of 18.8%. That means 81% of customers never place a second order. For a brand that spends to win every first order, that is the leak that matters most.

Acquiring a new customer costs 5 to 25 times more than keeping one, according to research by Cydcor cited by Shopify. A study of 146 Indian D2C brands found an average repeat purchase rate of 27%, and brands above 30% grew 2.6 times faster year over year than their peers. Repeat buyers are a small group. In a separate study of 13 D2C brands, the 23% of customers who bought more than once produced about 49% of total revenue.

What a good repeat purchase rate looks like in India

There is no single target. The right number depends on what you sell and how fast it runs out. ProfitBox360 research from 2025 puts the 90-day repeat purchase rate for Indian ecommerce at 33.5% for food and beverages, 30% for health and supplements, 28.3% for beauty and personal care, and 18% for fashion and apparel. Footwear sits at 13.5%, home and kitchen at 10.5%, jewellery at 9% and electronics at 8%. Across all categories, 27.5% of customers order again within 12 months.

Category90-day repeat purchase rate
Food and beverages33.5%
Health and supplements30%
Beauty and personal care28.3%
Fashion and apparel18%
Footwear13.5%
Home and kitchen10.5%
Jewellery9%
Electronics8%

Compare your rate with your own category, not with the all-category average. A fashion brand at 18% is at its benchmark. A skincare brand at 18% has work to do. The same Shopify analysis puts consumables at 22% to 44%, fashion at 10% to 17%, and durables and home goods at 7% to 18%.

Work out what a repeat customer is worth to you

Price the lift before you buy retention tools. Take a skincare brand that gains 1,000 new customers a month, with a repeat order value of ₹900. At the 28.3% beauty benchmark, 283 of them buy again within 90 days, worth ₹2,54,700 per monthly group. Lift the rate by three points to 31.3% and 313 buy again, worth ₹2,81,700. The extra 30 repeat buyers add ₹27,000 per monthly group, or ₹3,24,000 a year across 12 monthly groups. None of those orders needs new acquisition spend. Use your own repeat order value and your own rate, and the same maths tells you what a three-point lift is worth to you.

Fix the first order before chasing the second

Nobody comes back after a bad first order. Delivery is where most Indian D2C brands lose the second sale. Confirm COD orders on WhatsApp before dispatch, so fewer parcels come back as RTO. Ship on the day you promised, pack the product so it arrives in good shape, and put a clear return and exchange note inside the box. A customer who waits a week for a parcel that arrives damaged has no reason to order again.

GetResponse found in its 2026 Customer Loyalty Report that 67.3% of consumers felt brands valued new customers more than existing ones. Your first order is where you prove the opposite. A thank-you note, a how-to-use card for a skincare product, or a size guide that actually matches the garment all cost little and set up the second order.

Time the second order to when the product runs out

For anything that depletes, the second order has a natural date. A 30-day supply runs out around day 25 to day 30. Send a reorder reminder on WhatsApp or email a few days before that date, with a one-tap reorder link. Offer a refill pack or a larger pack on the second order, so the customer saves on shipping and you save on acquisition.

For fashion and footwear, there is no depletion clock. Save the customer size and style preference from the first order, then send new arrivals in the styles they already bought. For electronics, home products and jewellery, judge repeat over 12 months rather than 90 days, and remind customers before gifting occasions such as Raksha Bandhan and Diwali.

Build three flows and keep them simple

  • Post-purchase: order confirmation, dispatch update, delivery update, then a check-in two days after delivery asking how the product is working.
  • Replenishment: one reminder timed to when the pack runs out, with a direct link to reorder the same product.
  • Winback: one message when a customer passes your normal repurchase window without ordering, with a reason to return that is not only a discount.

WhatsApp carries most of this in India, but only with clear opt-in at checkout. Collect the opt-in, name your business in it, and give customers a simple way to stop promotional messages. Email still works for the longer messages, such as how-to guides and new collection launches. Use both, and do not send the same message on both channels on the same day.

Make the second order easier than the first

Every extra step between a returning customer and checkout costs you repeat orders. Keep their address and size saved, show a reorder button on their account page and in the post-purchase email, and offer subscribe and save for products people buy every month. A subscription turns a repeat purchase into a default, and it works best for consumables with a fixed usage cycle.

Loyalty points help when they reward repeat buying, not when they train customers to wait for a discount. Give points for a second order, for a review with a photo, and for a referral that converts. Keep the reward simple to understand and simple to redeem at checkout.

Measure it by cohort, not by dashboard

Shopify shows a returning customer rate on its dashboard, but that divides returning customers by everyone who ordered in the period, including loyal buyers from earlier years. It is not your repeat purchase rate. Use the customer cohort analysis report instead. Group first-time customers by the month of their first order, then count how many order again within 90 days. The formula is first-time customers who order again within 90 days, divided by all first-time customers in the group, times 100.

Match customers by phone number as well as email, so a guest checkout with a new email still counts as the same person. Read the rate only once every customer in the group has had a full 90 days. For a January group, that means early May. Then split the rate by first product, acquisition channel and payment method. COD buyers repeat at a different rate from prepaid buyers, and Meta buyers repeat at a different rate from search buyers. The split tells you where to spend.

The cheapest customer you will ever win is the one who already bought from you.

What to do this week

  • Pull your 90-day repeat purchase rate by cohort from Shopify, and write down your category benchmark next to it.
  • Check your last 20 first orders for delivery delays, damaged parcels and COD returns, and fix the most common problem first.
  • Set one replenishment reminder timed to when your best-selling product runs out.
  • Add a reorder button to your post-purchase email and your customer account page.
  • Send one winback message to customers who passed your normal repurchase window.

Get new posts by email

Practical D2C and Shopify notes from our team, one or two a month.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

We use your email only for what you asked for. Privacy notice

Written by the Pixel Caption growth teamNotes from the team that runs the work.
[ more notes ]

Keep reading

All posts

How many of your customers came back this month?

We look at your repeat rate, your first order experience and your retention flows, then tell you what to fix first.

Get a free growth audit

Pixel Captionnow